The American West offers some of the world’s best elk hunting opportunities—but nailing down the right tag isn’t always straightforward. States each have unique regulations, deadlines, and lottery systems, so a well-thought-out tag strategy can significantly boost your odds of punching that coveted elk tag. Below is an overview of how to navigate Western elk tag draws and maximize your potential for success.
1. Understand the States and Their Systems
- Over-the-Counter (OTC): Colorado ( very Few Now) , Idaho (in limited numbers), Oregon, Washington and parts of Montana offer OTC elk tags, but popularity means some OTC units may see high hunter pressure. If you want a “sure thing” for a license without waiting years, OTC is often your best bet. However, these OTC low success rate hunts are a great way to learn to be a better elk hunter.
- Limited-Entry/Drawing Systems: Wyoming, Arizona, New Mexico, Utah, and Nevada operate mostly limited-entry hunts. These typically require building bonus or preference points (or both), and being mindful of application deadlines. Although the learning curve is steep, the reward can be prime units with better animal quality and less competition.
2. Preference and Bonus Points
States use different point systems:
- Preference Points: Hunters with the most points draw first. Colorado and Wyoming have preference-point systems for specific species and hunts; the highest point-holders secure the top-tier tags.
- Bonus Points: Each point is like an extra “chance” in the draw, giving you better odds but not guaranteeing success. Arizona and Utah use variants of bonus-point systems.
If you plan to chase Upper tier bulls in good units, building points is essential. Research average point requirements for specific units, then decide how many years you’re willing to accumulate points before you expect a realistic chance at drawing.
3. Research Units Thoroughly
Some units have exceptional genetics, while others offer easier terrain or higher elk densities. Study state game-and-fish websites, look at harvest statistics, and connect with fellow hunters who have first-hand experience. Give extra attention to hunt dates and terrain difficulty—early archery tags might overlap with the elk rut but often mean unpredictable weather, whereas a late-season rifle hunt can produce a more challenging but also a higher chance at obtaining a tag.
4. Timing and Deadlines
Missed deadlines can derail an entire season. Each western state has unique application windows—some as early as January or February (Wyoming, Arizona), others in the spring (Colorado, New Mexico). Mark these dates on your calendar and make sure to confirm them annually, as states sometimes shift dates or revise tag allotments.
5. Balance Your Goals
No two hunters share the exact same priorities. Some focus on consistent yearly hunts via OTC tags to sharpen skills and get plenty of time afield. Others are willing to wait years for a premier tag in a sought-after unit. You might even choose a dual strategy, building points in multiple states while hunting OTC or easier-to-draw tags in the meantime.
6. Consider Professional Help
If time is short or you feel overwhelmed, professional tag consultants can help manage applications and provide unit-specific insights. Many outfitters also lend guidance on the application process when you book hunts. Alternatively, online resources, podcasts, and local forums are rich with advice if you prefer the DIY route.
Final Thoughts Elk tag strategy in the West is about long-term planning, a willingness to learn, and staying organized. Decide if you want a consistent annual hunt or if you’re patient enough to build points toward a once-in-a-lifetime unit. By studying each state’s system, researching units, and staying on top of deadlines, you’ll maximize your odds of hearing a bugling bull in your scope this coming fall—and in the seasons ahead.
TUNE INTO THIS EPISODE FOR A MORE DETAILED CONVERSATION OF TAG STRATEGY
Discover more from John Stallone Days in The Wild
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.